Consider the Tomato Pie

Tomato Pie 1

The Super Bowl approacheth (fingers are crossed), and if you want to offer your game-watching guests memorable party food that doesn’t involve Velveeta, you may well turn to the tomato pie. For the uninitiated, tomato pie is a stripped-down version of pizza, with all the basic elements of a Margherita except the molten cheese. But it’s hardly an ascetic option: In the ideal tomato pie, the sauce and crust are rich with olive oil, and each bite has a surprisingly velvety texture. (Granted, the tomato pie appeals to the more delicate eater, since you can’t just order a slice, fold the thing over and feel the grease running down your arm as you wolf it down between bar stops. With dozens of pieces per, it’s more of a premeditated affair.)

My personal favorite is from the Conshohocken “” better known to customers as “Conshy“ “” Bakery, where the square-shaped pie has a focaccia-like crust whose golden, faintly crisp edges frame a smooth blanket of tomato sauce and just a light sprinkling of pecorino cheese. The bakery also sells a few white pies with other toppings. Of these you should not miss the anchovy pie, a salty, pungent delectation that looks like the quilted top of a mattress buttoned with slivers of the tiny fish, garlic and rosemary. Both are fantastic heated or at room temperature so it’s a good idea to stash at least one in the freezer for unexpected party situations. Like Eagles victories.

Conshohocken Italian Bakery
79-83 Jones Street
Conshohocken, PA 19428



Leave a comment directly on the blog


  1. In my opinion, Conshy’s pie is less than mediocre, while Marchiano’s in Manayunk is is the best!

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *